DEBORAH CAMERON
- Cameron criticised the idea that there are natural differences in male and female speech
- ‘idea of men and women using language in different ways for different reasons is a great myth’
- Cameron discusses how this myth has progressed – we now believe that men have a natural desire to be competitive (aggressive speech style) – women talk about relationships and feelings
- Says that these myths have moulded our expectations of men and women and linguist behaviour that we believe is normal
- Cameron’s work mainly focuses on how speakers construct gendered identities for themselves
- This could challenge or draw in stereotypes
- Theorist Janet Hyde suggests that men and women language is actually similar due to said variables; age, class ethnicity
Men
|
Women
|
Dominate conversation by topic initiation, topic shifts, holding the
floor, interrupting and speaking more.
|
More submissive in a conversation and likely to speak less. Unlikely
to interrupt, initiate or change topics.
|
Use an informal register through their use if accent, taboo, slang,
dialect, sociolect etc.. Likely to use covert prestige to sustain a masculine
identity.
|
More likely to use overt prestige to help create a feminine identity
and succumb to stereotypes on how a ‘lady’ should talk.
|
More likely to be factual, competitive, direct and detached when
speaking while maintaining a need for status.
|
More likely to be supportive, cooperative, polite, apologetic when
speaking.
|
No comments:
Post a Comment